Rating: 9.5/10
A couple years back I went through what I guess you could call a “musical theatre phase” where I was obsessed with Broadway and listened to Broadway musical soundtracks religiously. It lasted for about a year or so, and then I just kind of stopped and started listening to non-theatre music. However, about a month ago, I for some reason decided to re-listen to the Spring Awakening soundtrack (because that was one of the shows that I used to listen to, though I didn’t listen to it as much as I listened to other musicals) and I was absolutely blown away by how good this musical is. And now I’m getting back into my theatre phase, so I thought it might be fun to do reviews for some of my favorite Broadway shows, starting with this one because it’s my all-time favorite.
Now that I’ve informed you all of my history with Broadway musicals, we can get into the ranking of all the songs on the 2006 Broadway musical, Spring Awakening, listing the songs from my least favorite to my favorite. Here we go!
19. Mama Who Bore Me (Track 1)
This musical has two types of songs; super punk-rockish bangers, and gentle, weepy, orchestra-oriented ballads. Unfortunately, this song falls into the latter category. Don’t get me wrong, there are other songs on this soundtrack that are also in that category that I really like, but this one just doesn’t do it for me. It’s slow and kind of dreary and, even though Lea Michele sounds beautiful, it’s very boring to me. I will say that it does a good job of setting up the themes of the show and the violins are pretty, but those are pretty much the only things I appreciate about it.
18. The Song of Purple Summer (Track 19)
Funny how, in my opinion, the opener and closer of this show are the weakest songs. This isn’t a bad song at all, I can see why they chose it to be the finale. There are some beautiful harmonies and the message ends the show on a hopeful, optimistic note. But it’s just a bit of a snooze, really. I wish they would’ve gone with something more dynamic and out-there for the finale.
17. The Word of Your Body (Reprise) (Track 16)
This song is cute and all, but it just falls a bit short, and I think it could’ve been better. If it had been less restrained and a bit more upbeat then I think I would like it more (I understand that what’s happening in the song is very tender and intimate, so it makes sense for the song to be tender and intimate, but on a purely musical level it doesn’t click with me as much). Still, the group harmonies at the end are absolutely stunning and elevate the last portion of the song high above the rest of it.
16. I Believe (Track 11)
The guitar and harmonies in this song make a really good combination and give the song a mildly hymn-like vibe, which I think might’ve been intentional. This song is pretty stagnant all throughout (if you’ve seen the show and know what’s happening during this number you’ll understand why. The song itself isn’t really the focus of the scene) except for at the end where vocals start to layer and interweave, and it adds a very grandiose flourish to the Act I closer. But other than that, the song’s pretty dull, and it’s only interesting if you know what’s happening during the song in the context of the show’s plot.
15. Whispering (Track 17)
“Had a sweetheart on his knees, so faithful and adoring. And he touched me, and I let him love me, so let that be my story.” For the show’s narrative, ‘Whispering’ is essential for both the plot and Wendla’s character. It shows Wendla taking ownership of her decisions and finally reaching the wisdom and maturity she had been longing for up until that point. Lea’s vocal performance is really good and adds to the contemplative nature of the song. The best part of this song for me, as I hinted at earlier, is Wendla finally reaching self-empowerment. However, musically, it’s just not really my thing.
14. Mama Who Bore Me (Reprise) (Track 2)
The reprise of this song is a lot more dynamic than the original, which is why I have it 5 spots higher. Instead of one voice with a violin instrumental, this version has a percussion instrumental with several harmonized, overlapping voices and it’s much more fun to listen to. Granted, it’s still not one of my favorites to listen to off the soundtrack, but it’s decent.
13. The Word of Your Body (Track 7)
I didn’t like this song at all when I first listened to it (it also falls into the weepy, strings-ballad category) but it’s grown on me. It’s a great duet for Jonathan and Lea and their voices blend so well with the tone and nature of the song. I guess I like this version of the song better than the reprise because it feels more sensual. This song is essential in the development of both the show’s themes and Melchior and Wendla’s relationship, and though it’s not an absolute favorite, it’s not bad at all.
12. The Dark I Know Well (Track 8)
This song’s subject matter is pretty dark, so I’m not gonna get into it, but I will say that it seems to deal with the topic in an empathetic way, which is good. Looking past the subject matter, the song sounds great. The girls singing sound incredible and the instrumental is very moody and angry, which fits the tone of the song.
11. The Mirror-Blue Night (Track 10)
This song is a little strange, but when you get into the head-space to listen to it, it’s pretty enjoyable. Jonathan gives a great vocal performance – he does a great job of portraying Melchior’s curiosity and frustration. Also, the string section that occurs about a minute in is stunning and adds a beautiful, mystical quality to the song. The group harmonies from the boys are lovely and are a very nice way to frame the song. Overall, a solid number and very important for Melchior’s character arc. “But there’s nowhere to hide from the ghost in my mind. It’s cold in these bones of a man and a child. And there’s no one who knows, and there’s nowhere to go. There’s no one to see who can see to my soul.”
10. Totally F**ked (Track 15)
Okay, this song is obviously very profane (as you can assume by the title, which I’ve censored) but it’s such a blast. What a great anthem for realizing that when there’s nothing you can do to help a situation, you might as well just give in and have fun with whatever comes along. The boys all give great vocals, and the group chorus is so fun to sing along to and jump around to it. I will say, this scene is even better in the actual performance of the show.
9. Those You’ve Known (Track 18)
‘Those You’ve Known’ makes me so sad every time I listen to it, but it’s so beautiful. John Gallagher Jr.’s voice as he opens up the song is absolutely chilling but in the best way. And the way Lea Michele comes in as the tempo picks up is also stunning. Then when the main chorus of the song comes in with both of them singing their different parts, overlapping over each other is fantastic (then Jonathan joins in and it gets EVEN BETTER). The song’s ending always makes me want to cry because it’s so touching. Thematically, this song is probably the most poignant in the entire show. Moritz’ part sums up his character arc, Wendla’s sums up hers, and Melchior’s sums up his. With the melody from ‘All That’s Known’ returning, it’s an incredibly smart way to show how Melchior has grown and changed over the course of the musical. Basically, this song is absolutely beautiful but very bittersweet and melancholy, so I don’t gravitate towards it as often. “Now they’ll walk on my arm through the distant night, and I won’t let them stray from my heart. Through the wind, through the dark, through the winter light – I will read all their dreams to the stars. I’ll walk now with them, I’ll call on their names. And I’ll see their thoughts are known, not gone, not gone.”
8. All That’s Known (Track 3)
“You watch me, just watch me. I’m calling, and one day all will know.” Okay, this and ‘Those You’ve Known’ are basically tied, but this one is easier to listen to so I have it one spot higher. This is a great introduction to Melchior’s character, setting him up as the radical, forward-thinking, curious protagonist that he is. The guitar and strings combination gives the instrumental a very introspective quality, and Jonathan’s vocal performance (as I’ve said many times) is truly great. His portrayal as Melchior is amazing and you can really tell in this song, because as he’s singing, he really sounds like a young man who’s frustrated with the purposeful ignorance of everyone around him. Like I said, the melody of this song is later reprised in ‘Those You’ve Known’ with this song serving as a representation of how Melchior starts out, and ‘Those You’ve Known’ serving as a representation of how he ends up. It’s brilliant and I love it. Both songs are just great. Oh, and the Latin chanting that frames the song is an awesome touch.
7. Don’t Do Sadness/Blue Wind (Track 12)
FINALLY – a Moritz song! I can finally talk about him and his storyline! Just so ya’ll know, Moritz is my favorite character in the show, and his songs are definitely the best in my opinion – probably because they best encapsulate the rock, punk-influenced side of this soundtrack. The sentiment he’s expressing in this song is really heartbreaking (basically him saying he’s fed up with all the mental exhaustion and pain he’s been bottling up for so long), but I mean… he sounds great. The angry cellos that open up the song really set the stage for the angst-fest that ensues, and John Gallagher Jr. does a great job of portraying a miserable Moritz releasing all his pent-up anger and frustration.
Ilse’s part in this song is very pretty and she sounds very wistful and nostalgic. The guitar that plays while she croons is very soft and it does a nice job of showing the contrast between the head-spaces of the two characters. However, when she and Moritz start to duet at the end, THAT’S WHEN IT GETS REAL. Oh man that parts slaps so hard.
6. The Guilty Ones (Track 13)
So when I said that there are some songs that fall into the “orchestra-ballad” category that I actually like a lot, this is one of them. This song is so pretty and it really took me by surprise. The strings that open up the song are stunning, and Wendla’s soft, withdrawn voice for her verse is lovely. Then the chorus hits, and between the piano line that’s brought in and the quiet, backing group vocals, it’s amazing. Then Melchior’s verse comes in and a drum beat is added, and he sounds awesome, AND IT’S ALL SO GOOD. THIS SONG IS SO PRETTY AND CALMING I LOVE IT.
5. My Junk (Track 5)
What a lovely, charming, sweet little number. This song just radiates youthfulness and girly-innocence and the exhilarating, giddy rush of falling for someone. The girls really get their chance to shine here, and the way they rotate lines during the verses then come together for the intoxicating chorus is just perfect. I loveeee singing this song. The melody is so pretty and the harmonies are gorgeous. It’s just a wonderful song.
4. Left Behind (Track 14)
“The talks you never had, the Saturdays you never spent. All the grown-up places you never went. And all of the crying you wouldn’t understand. You just let him cry, make a man out of him.” This song breaks my heart. It’s so beautiful but so full of remorse and disappointment. Just from the opening guitar strums I already want to cry, it’s so sad and emotional. Jonathan Groff sounds beautiful and haunting here, and you can feel the sadness and bitterness that Melchior is feeling. This song is even sadder for me because Moritz is my favorite character (I’m not gonna get into any details ’cause I don’t wanna spoil the story for anyone, but if you know the show then you’ll of course know what I’m talking about). The strings are gorgeous, and the melody is enchantingly somber and full of longing. The lyrics are gut-wrenching but very poignant. Oh, and I guess this song also has a special place in my heart because it was the first one I heard from Spring Awakening.
3. And Then There Were None (Track 9)
YAY ANOTHER MORITZ SONG!! This song is so good guys. SO GOOD. Moritz has my whole heart. The jaunty little guitar-plucking line that runs through the whole song is so fun, and Moritz’ annoyed attitude throughout his parts feels so real and authentic. I listen to this song a lot, especially when I’n frustrated, because it just captures the feeling of utter annoyance and resentment so well. And his voice in the “they freak or won’t” part is beautiful, and the backing vocals in that part are as well. The way that all the boys come together to sing at the end is so cool and they sound amazing together. In summation, this song fuels me, and it’s just fantastic in every way.
2. Touch Me (Track 6)
Wow. Just wow. I mean, what a stunning piece of art this song is. I probably sound like I’m being dramatic, but I’m dead serious. This is one of the most gorgeous songs I’ve heard in all of musical theatre (or just in general). I don’t even know where to begin. The opening guitar sets up the tone of the song so well, and the way Melchior begins the song is haunting. Moritz’ has such an earnestness and fascination in his voice during his part, and both he and Melchior carry the poignancy of the lyrics so well.
The strings in this song are truly beautiful and give the song such an emotive and powerful feeling. The background vocals are just as prominent in establishing the emotive nature of the song. Not to mention that when Otto and George burst through with such power and passion in the second chorus, it just leaves you in awe. I also have this weird affinity for the part where Melchior and Moritz are singing the “tell me please, all is forgiven” part about halfway through the song. It makes me feel so happy and warm.
And yes, okay I know the subject matter of this song is a little… inappropriate, but hey. It’s a real thing and it’s sung about with such care and delicacy. The lyrics here are just as stunning as the music, and I could write a whole dissertation on the lyrical content of this song, but seeing as my spiel for this song is already long enough, I’ll just leave this as it is. Honestly, do yourself a favor and listen to this one. You’ll drift away, I swear. “Where I go, when I go there, no more whispering anymore. Only hymns upon your lips, a mystic wisdom, rising with them to shore.”
1. The B**ch of Living (Track 4)
And here we have the BANGER TO END ALL BANGERS. THIS SONG SLAPS SOOOOOOO HARD IT’S NOT EVEN FUNNY. Honestly, I’ve probably listened to this song at least 500 times over the past month alone, and I’m not even remotely sick of it. That’s how good it is, okay? And sure, the subject matter here is pretty inappropriate, but like I said for ‘Touch Me’ it’s a real thing that teenagers go through, and it’s dealt with in a realistic way. Everything about this song gives me life. Moritz sounds so good here. But all the guys do. They really took the cake with this one. The chorus is so emphatic and full of passion and impatience and frustration. The backing vocals are so fun and pretty, and the part where they all start to sing in unison as Melchior finally joins the song — CHILLS. The melody is so freaking infectious and it just gets into your soul and leaves you no choice but to get up and jump around with joy and exuberance. Also the lyric, “It’s the bi**ch of living just getting out of bed.” hits way harder than it should’ve. If I haven’t compelled you to give this a listen then I don’t know what else I can do. It’s just perfection. I couldn’t be more obsessed with this sing.