Rating: 9.5/10
With Midnight Memories, One Direction started to move away from the bubblegum-pop sound of their first two albums and into a more mature realm of songwriting. While I think that Midnight Memories is a great album, I also think it only planted the seeds for what became One Direction’s unique, personal sound. Four is the full bloom, and it sounds more artistic and personal than anything that came before it.
For me, there isn’t a bad song on this entire album. It’s near-perfect, and practically tied with their last album (for now) as my favorite from the band. Four sees 1D taking on a laid-back and groovy ’80s sound (I’d say the definining musical features are super strong harmonies and old-school guitar work), and I think they pulled it off amazingly.
In this post, I’ll be ranking all the songs on 1D’s fourth studio album, creatively titled Four, from my least-favorite to my favorite. Just keep in mind that I actually love every single song on this record, so this is going to be really hard for me.
16. Change Your Ticket (Track 13)
This isn’t a bad song by any means, but it doesn’t really fit on the album if you ask me. I mean, it’s not super out of place, but it sounds like it would’ve worked better on Midnight Memories. And also, it’s just a little more shallow than the rest of the songs on the album, but still. It’s good, just not great.
15. Ready to Run (Track 2)
“There’s a devil in your smile, it’s chasing me, and every time I turn around, it’s only gaining speed. There’s a moment when you finally realize, there’s no way you can change the rolling tide. But I know, yes I know that I’ll be fine.” I’m pretty sure this a lot of people’s favorite from the album, and don’t get me wrong, I like it, but it’s just not one of my top favorites. The thing with this song is that I like the lyrics A LOT but the sonic direction they went with isn’t really my thing. Like I said for Change Your Ticket, I think this song would’ve fit well on Midnight Memories, because that album has a lot more folk-characterization than this one. “This time I’m ready to run. Escape from the city and follow the sun.”
14. Act My Age (Track 16)
Okay, I want to make it clear right off the bat that I will tolerate no Act My Age slander. This is an everlasting bop, and the best Irish-jig we could’ve hoped for. As I said, this ranking is very difficult for me because I genuinely enjoy and appreciate each song on this record. I want to rank Act My Age higher because it’s super fun, and I hate when people hate on it, but I have to put it here. I’m sorry Niall.
13. 18 (Track 4)
This was written by Ed Sheeran, which makes sense, because it’s a great lyrical ballad that makes you feel kind of nostalgic. This song is about a love from your teenage years that you look back on and wish you could revisit. This is a very sweet song, and I always enjoy it. Also, I just wanna say that the part in the bridge where it slows down and Louis comes in singing all nice and gently… HEAVENLY.
12. Steal My Girl (Track 1)
Okay, here’s where we’re starting to reach the songs that I really really like but aren’t absolute favorites. I love Steal My Girl. It’s a classic One Direction song, it’s booming, swoon-worthy, and incredibly catchy. It was a great choice for lead single, and an effortless radio hit. Lyrically, it doesn’t have as much depth as other songs on the record, which is why I don’t have it higher up, but I’m very much of the belief that a song doesn’t have to be some heart-wrenching, wise ballad to be a good song. Also, I don’t know if anyone will understand what I mean by this, but this song sounds like what a sunset looks like. You know?
11. Illusion (Track 14)
When those opening harmonies begin, let me tell you, I LEVITATE. WHO GAVE THEM THE RIGHT TO SOUND SO AMAZING? Harmonies are one of my musical weaknesses, and this song uses them pretty heavily in the chorus and hook, so needless to say, Illusion is a win for me. The weird thing is, I didn’t love this song when I first listened to the album (it just didn’t stick out much to me), but now I bop to it whenever I hear it.
10. Spaces (Track 10)
Man, I would’ve loved to see this live. This is a truly great song. It’s booming and grand, but it still feels a bit slow (in a good way). This album as a whole has a very booming, arena-rock feel to it, and this is a great example of that. This sounds like it was written for the sake of being performed for thousands of people at once. There’s a really emotional quality to this song for me, but I can’t really place what it is. I mean, the lyrics aren’t exactly happy, but something about the way that it’s sung just really gets me. Maybe it’s Harry. He really stands out on this song, and I think he sounds very emotive. The way he sings “even though I’ve tried” is so beautiful. Also, just to add onto all that – I really like the guitar section after the chorus. “Oh, spaces between us keep getting deeper. It’s harder to reach you even though I’ve tried. Spaces between us, hold all our secrets, leaving us speechless and I don’t know why. Who’s gonna be the first to say goodbye?”
9. Clouds (Track 12)
This is the closer for the standard edition of the album, which I think was an interesting choice. This song is very sonically upbeat, which isn’t typically the direction they went for with their finales. Still, this is an awesome song. I heard that they used to open up the OTRA shows with this song, and just… wow. That must’ve been really fricking epic to experience. This song just gets you pumped up and passionate. From the slick and insanely epic guitar riff in the chorus to Harry’s soaring vocals, this song is just so cool, and such an exciting track to listen to. Like, I literally bounce whenever I hear the chorus. It just gets you kind of pent-up. I dare you to listen to this and not scream along “HERE! WE! GO AGAIN!” whenever the chorus starts. It’s pretty much impossible.
Also side note (this is going to sound so incredibly stupid and niche but if you see it you’re gonna see it): I feel like this song sounds like an old Pokemon theme song? Like the chorus just gives me Pokemon theme song vibes. I hope someone reading this agrees with me.
8. Fool’s Gold (Track 6)
This is a really sad song, but it’s so calming and pleasant to listen to. I mean, it’s beautiful. Lyrically, it’s one of the best and most interesting on the album (in my humble opinion). This song is about having someone in your life who you know doesn’t truly care about you, someone who gives the same love they give you to a bunch of other people, but you love them a lot so you decide to stay with them. It’s a very real and vulnerable topic, and I really love that 1D reached a point where they could write songs about things like that. “And yes, I let you use me from the day that we first met, but I’m not done yet, falling for you, fool’s gold. And I knew then, you turned it on for everyone you met, but I don’t regret falling for you, fool’s gold.”
7. Girl Almighty (Track 5)
Okay, try to imagine: I didn’t even like this song when I first listened to it. I don’t even know why, there’s no excuse. I suppose I just thought it was a boring, bubblegum-pop number. I don’t know what I was on, though, because this song is amazing. For starters, it’s SO fun to sing. Secondly, it always gets me dancing. Thirdly, the vocals are great. Fourth, THE GUITAR. There’s a lot of great instrumentation in this song (the drumming is awesome) but the use of guitar in this song is impeccable. If you really listen to all the guitar work throughout this track, IT’S SO GOOD.
6. Once in a Lifetime (Track 15)
The penultimate track of the deluxe edition, Once in a Lifetime is a very mellow and breezy song (it’s the ‘Summer Love’ of Four). I think both this and Act My Age were good candidates for the closer. Act My Age ends the album on a lighthearted and carefree note, while this song would’ve ended it on a nostalgic and wistful note. The harmonies in this song are GORGEOUS, and I love how they basically harmonize for the entire chorus. Really, I just like how simple and effortlessly beautiful this song is. Acoustic guitar and harmonies – my two weaknesses. Also, just to point out: I really like how they strum on muted guitar strings in the beginning to open up the track. An interesting choice, but I like the way it turned out. “Somehow, it feels like nothing has changed. Right now, my heart is beating the same. Out loud, someone’s calling my name. It sounds like you. When I close my eyes, all the stars align and you are by my side.”
5. No Control (Track 8)
After the somewhat slowed-down and somber duo of Fool’s Gold and Night Changes, No Control is the song that’s used to bring back an upbeat sound and tempo for the album. Man, this song is great. I’m pretty much saying this right off the top of my head, but I’d probably say that this is the most beloved non-single song from 1D’s entire discography. Seriously, you’d be hard-pressed to find any Directioner who doesn’t love this song. One of my favorite things about this song is how much Louis shines. Louis doesn’t usually get as many vocal moments in a song as some of the other members, but he gets the whole chorus in this song AND HE SLAYS IT. Overall, this is just such a catchy and infectious song, and it’s hard not to dance and sing along to it whenever you hear it.
4. Stockholm Syndrome (Track 11)
This song is pop music done to absolute perfection. Everything that I like about pop music, this song has it. A driving rythym, incredible vocals, an interesting story and concept, and an infectious quality that makes it impossible not to sing along. Harry wrote this song, and he’s said that it uses Stockholm syndrome (a syndrome where you fall in love with someone who kidnaps you) as a metaphor for being enchanted by someone who isn’t that good for you. It’s just a really cool song, and one of the most definitive songs on the album in terms of establishing a unique sound for the band.
3. Where Do Broken Hearts Go (Track 3)
“Yeah, the taste of your lips on the tip of my tongue is at the top of the list of the things I want. Mind is running in circles of you and me, anyone in between is the enemy. Shadows come with the pain that you’re running from, love was something you never heard enough. Yeah, it took me some time but I figured out how to fix up a heart that I let down.” I think this is an amazing song, and it was amazingly well done. Kinda think it should’ve been a single because I’m sure the music video would’ve turned out amazing, and I bet it would’ve been a radio smash. Something really cool about this song is that it’s sort of a breakup song, but it isn’t depressing. It manages to convey the feelings of regret and longing and urgency without being overwrought and sappy, and it just feels really genuine. Sonically, it’s gorgeous (lyrically as well) and it’s just an absolute delight to listen to. Definitely one of my favorite 1D songs ever! “Now I’m searching every lonely place, every corner calling out your name. Tryna find you but I just don’t know, where do broken hearts go? Are you sleeping, baby, by yourself, or are you giving it to someone else?“
2. Fireproof (Track 9)
I was sold on this song from the very first time I heard it. Even during first time listening to Four as a whole, I knew as soon as I heard Fireproof that it was gonna be top 3. It’s just that good. This is the smooth-rock jam that everyone needs in their life. From the opening guitar riff, to the driving drum beat that gives the whole song rhythym, as well as the relaxed and gliding vocals and stunning harmonies, this song is pretty much perfect. Not to mention, the lyrics are really good too.
1. Night Changes (Track 7)
I don’t even know where to begin with this song. It has such a special place in my heart, I’ll never really be able to properly express what it means to me, but I’ll try. For a little bit of background: I’d casually enjoyed One Direction’s music growing up, but I never really went out of my way to listen to them, and you couldn’t have really called me a proper fan. A few months ago, I was randomly going through old throwback songs on YouTube and I ended up watching a few 1D music videos. I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their music, but I still held back from deciding to become a fan due to preconceptions about the band (which I quickly came to realize were false of course). Then, I ended up watching the Night Changes music video, and right when I heard this song, I knew I was a fan. So to make a long story short: this was the song that sold me on the band and turned me into the fan I am now. And to this day, it remains my absolute favorite One Direction song ever. It’s so incredibly beautiful and sweet and heartfelt. There’s such a nostalgic and reminiscent and comforting presence to be found in this song. The main message of this song is that everyone will have a certain point in their life where they become mature and they have to grow up, but there’s no reason to worry about it because it’s natural, and it won’t change who you are at heart. Sonically, this song is breathtaking. All of the boys do an amazing job with their parts (Harry absolutely KILLS me in the chorus. No one could’ve done it better than him) and don’t even get me started on THE KEY CHANGE AND HARMONIES RIGHT BEFORE THE BRIDGE. I GET CHILLS EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. Not only is this my favorite 1D song ever, it’s one of my favorite songs of all time. The lyrics are so atmospheric and descriptive, they paint such a strong picture of what’s occurring. In short: this song is absolute perfection. “We’re only getting older, baby, and I’ve been thinking about you lately. Does it ever drive you crazy, just how fast the night changes? Everything that you’ve ever dreamed of, disappearing when you wake up, but there’s nothing to be afraid of. Even when the night changes, it will never change me and you.“ Those are some wise, wise words, and I live by them.